Home / Infectious Diseases / Beyond the Pathogens: Antimicrobial Resistance in the Environment

Beyond the Pathogens: Antimicrobial Resistance in the Environment

overhead scene of a wastewater treatment facility

When we talk about antibiotic resistance, the focus is usually on bacteria that make us sick. The most unfortunate of these cases show attempt after attempt to use different antibiotics to treat an infection with no end in sight. Antimicrobial resistance, or AMR for short, is a major global health threat, which accounted for over 4.7 million deaths in 2021. If things continue as they are, the numbers will keep increasing. 

Antibiotic resistance doesn’t just appear out of nowhere. Bacteria can become resistant to antibiotics through mutations in their DNA or by getting resistance genes from other bacteria. These bacteria can then continue to spread the genes to other bacteria as well. Still, not all bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics make you sick. So why does this matter?

How does antimicrobial resistance spread?

Antimicrobial resistance in bacteria that don’t make us sick matters because these bacteria can spread antimicrobial resistance genes to bacteria that make us sick. Microbes are everywhere so there’s ample opportunity for pathogenic bacteria to pick up DNA from other bacteria they encounter or DNA fragments in the environment. These pieces of DNA could contain antimicrobial resistance genes.

Three ways that AMR genes spread include:

  1. Conjugation: Microbes that aren’t pathogens can transfer AMR genes to pathogens directly if they’re close by. 
  2. Transformation: Pathogens can also pick up AMR genes from their surroundings, for example, when a non-pathogen dies and releases its DNA. 
  3. Transduction: Viruses that infect bacteria (aka phages) can pick up DNA (including AMR genes) and inject them into pathogenic bacteria. 

Common sources of antimicrobial resistance genes

Years ago on this blog, we covered the antibiotic resistance gene carbapenemase, blaNDM-1. It was first identified in 2008 in a urine sample from a patient who was hospitalized in India. In 2010, the gene was detected in seepage water in India and was later found in soil samples in the Arctic in 2013. This example shows that antimicrobial resistance genes can persist in multiple different types of environments over various timespans. Many of these sources all have one thing in common: wastewater.

Below, we’ll take a look at the common sources of antibiotic/antibiotic resistance genes and how it ends up in wastewater. 

Livestock

In the 1950s, farmers found out that giving low doses of antibiotics to livestock made them grow faster. Farmers also started using antibiotics for disease prevention, while the proper use of antibiotics is as a treatment. Adding small doses of antibiotics to livestock feed became commonplace and in 2020, 99,502 tons of antibiotics were used in feed for cattle, sheep, chicken, and pigs globally. 

These animals then secrete these antimicrobials (think: poop), making their way into the environment such as in the soil and eventually wastewater. These low-dose exposures provided an economic benefit to these farmers in the short-term, but this is outweighed by bigger problems in terms of antimicrobial resistance that span the industry and human health.

To learn more about antibiotic use in agriculture, I recommend Maryn McKenna’s book Big Chicken. 

What you can do: Look for meat from animals that were raised without antibiotics.

Aquaculture

Similar for livestock, antibiotics in aquaculture have been used both to treat disease and as a prophylactic. One study estimated 10,259 tons of antimicrobials were used in 2017 globally and projected this number to increase by 33% in 2030.

What you can do: Don’t purchase seafood that has been raised using antibiotics.

Sewage

When we take antimicrobials, some of this makes their way into feces and into the sewers. Because sewage brings together residual antimicrobials, bacteria (some of which may already be resistant to some drugs), and antimicrobial resistance genes, it becomes a place where resistance genes can transfer between pathogens and non-pathogenic bacteria. If not treated properly, some of these bacteria or DNA can make their way into treated water.

What you can do: Don’t dump unused medication down the drain. Use a medical waste disposal site in your area (these are sometimes located at a pharmacy or police station).

Hospitals and medical facilities

With the number of antibiotics used on site, it’s no surprise that hospitals are a source for antimicrobial resistance genes. A systematic review looked at 37 studies on the prevalence of AMR bacteria and AMR genes in hospitals vs. community wastewater. Thirty of the 37 studies found higher frequencies of antimicrobial resistant bacteria and genes in hospital wastewater compared to community wastewater. Not surprisingly, wastewater from hospital sewers is associated with higher selection of multiple resistances in bacteria exposed to hospital wastewater compared to bacteria exposed to municipal wastewater.

What you can do: If your doctor prescribes an antibiotic, ask if it’s really necessary or if it’s possible to wait to start the antibiotic until test results come back. Note that sometimes, you can’t do this because the potential benefit from starting the antibiotic is greater and you may risk worsening conditions by waiting.

Pharmaceuticals

When manufacturers create antibiotics, some fraction of that is liquid waste that contains concentrated antibiotics. Before making its way into receiving water such as rivers, it needs to be treated to reduce antibiotic concentrations. This is because antibiotic residues can select for resistant bacteria and lead to the spread of resistance genes in the environment. However, dilution alone isn’t a complete solution in and of itself as low concentrations can still create selective pressure.

To read more, I found the Access to Medicine Foundation’s AMR report and the WHO Guidance on wastewater for antibiotic manufacturers helpful.

What you can do: It’s not really realistic for consumers to identify a “clean” manufacturer on their own nor is it safe to skip or switch a prescription based on manufacturing concerns without discussing it with a clinician. Instead, action here could mean contacting elected representatives to support cleaner antibiotic and drug manufacturing and waste disposal.

It’s a One Health kind of world

All of these examples illustrate One Health, or the idea that humans, animals, and the environment are all interconnected and impacting one another. A common theme here is that everything ends up in wastewater. This is important because more than half of wastewater makes it into the environment with little or no treatment, which can promote the spread of antimicrobial resistance into new populations and new bacteria. 

While we can make choices on the individual level, antimicrobial stewardship requires better farming practices, sanitation, and manufacturing controls on a larger scale to make an impact.

Featured image source: Wikideas1

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.